Title: The Killing Joke
Genre: Graphic Novel
Year: 1988
Pages: 60
Origin: read on the iPad
Nod Rating: 3 nods out of 5
The first read of The Killing Joke – some seven or so years
previously – was an engaging one. Having not been a comic-reading enthusiast in
his youth, it was the Worm’s first real immersion into the genre. It was dark,
action-packed, with an interesting narrative that took into account the (supposed)
beginnings of Batman’s arch-nemesis, the Joker. As such, the Worm joined the
ranks of others who supported its influence and special place within graphic
novel history.
Second-time round always brings new surprises. This time the
Worm had the experience of feasting on other Batman storylines (particularly
that of Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns), as well as more of Sir Moore’s
back catalogue (including the excellent The Watchmen). This time the journey
was not as engaging or surprising, with the Worm’s comic-book reading critical
eye shrugging at some of the lacklustre dialogue, and becoming disinterested at
the shock-factor of the shooting of Gordon’s daughter. Furthermore, some of the
plot seemed rushed, including the Joker’s origin back-story. In what is an
otherwise downbeat review, what of the positives? Reading the 2008 deluxe
reprint it is clear of the highlights of the artwork of Bollard.
The Killing Joke remains a crucial read for anyone serious
in their devotion to Batman, or indeed, to that of Sir Alan Moore (yes, the
Worm has knighted him). 3 nods may appear slightly unkind, but the Worm is not
one for sentiments. Furthermore, this reviewer believes that the reading
experience may become good once again, third-time round. See you in another
seven or so years, Killing Joke.
